3.5 Stars. I liked it, I wanted to LOVE it so I think that made me have too high expectations. I hate when I do that to myself. I love DARK. The darker the better really. I would say my main problem (if you call it a problem) was the love at first sight between Grant and Renata. I am a huge fan of love at first sight so I am not sure why this didn't work out so great for me?!? It had back story galore so it wasn't rushed with the characters, I felt like I knew both of them very well. I wanted to be excited about the instalove, i just never was=( I am not bashing this book because it held my interest but I just wanted more. I am def going to read the second book, I have a feeling that it will be better!